Nadiem Makarim Accused of Causing IDR 2.1 Trillion in State Losses Over Chromebook and Chrome Device Management (CDM) Procurement
In fact, the Chromebook procurement saved at least IDR 1.2 trillion in state budget, primarily by cutting operating system licensing and device management costs.
In fact, the Chromebook procurement saved at least IDR 1.2 trillion in state budget, primarily by cutting operating system licensing and device management costs.
The free operating system license and a one-time Device Management licensing scheme make Chromebooks, overall, cheaper than laptops in other ecosystems.
The use of Chromebooks in the national ICT procurement program was not a policy that harmed state finances; rather, it was a deliberate cost-efficiency strategy for managing ICT infrastructure at a national scale.
In the context of national ICT procurement, the costs involved are not limited to the purchase of hardware such as laptops. The government must also account for other costs , including:
Operating system (OS) licensing
Centralized device management costs
Compared to laptops using other operating systems such as Windows, these two cost components are significantly lower in the Chromebook ecosystem.
Chromebook Cost Structure
At the time the procurement took place, the Chromebook cost structure consisted of several key elements designed to reduce government spending.
Chrome OS
FREE, or not subject to any additional licensing fee
The operating system cost is already included in the device price
Chrome Device Management (CDM)
One-time license (one-time fee)
Device management one-time fee of USD 30 per laptop
No subscription fee that must be renewed every year
Integrated Learning Applications
Chromebooks provide various integrated learning applications for free
Includes Google Workspace and Google Classroom, with no additional licensing fees
Comparison with Other Operating Systems
As a comparison, laptops using other operating systems such as Windows generates higher and recurring costs, including:
Paid operating system licensing fees per device (not free)
Subscription-based device management, with total management costs that can reach USD 200–230 for three years and must be paid repeatedly
Additional licensing fees for supporting learning software, such as document-processing and presentation tools
At the scale of national procurement, these cost differences save the state budget, not the other way around.
Why Is Chrome Device Management (CDM) Essential?
Device Management referred to in the Chromebook ecosystem as Chrome Device Management (CDM) plays a critical role in ensuring accountability, a utilization monitoring system, long-term risk management, and, most importantly, protecting students from harmful content such as pornography, online gambling, and violent games.
Procurement Accountability
The Ministry of Education, Culture, Research, and Technology (Kemendikbudristek) needs to ensure that ICT devices purchased are properly distributed and received by schools. Device Management enables:
Identifying and monitoring who activates each laptop
Tracking the location and device usage
Collecting utilization data on a regular basis
Utilization Monitoring System
Through CDM, laptop usage can be monitored to ensure devices are used responsibly. Chromebook Device Management allows remote centralized control by the Super Admin (PUSDATIN, Ministry of Education), including the ability to:
Block irrelevant or harmful websites (social media, violent games, pornography, intrusive advertising)
Centrally manage which applications can be installed
Automatically install applications without requiring teachers to install them one by one, thereby significantly reducing training and operational costs across regions
Disable internet access centrally during examinations, such as the National Assessment, to prevent potential cheating
All of these mechanisms ensure that devices are used solely for learning and school administration purposes while minimizing the risk of misuse beyond learning purposes.
As a result of the implementation of Chrome Device Management (CDM), physical audits at schools are no longer required, because each laptop’s usage activity at every school is recorded in real time. For the first time in Indonesia’s history, the conduct of ICT procurement can be 100% transparent and accountable.
Allegation
Allegations have emerged that the procurement of Chromebooks and Chrome Device Management (CDM) caused state financial losses up to IDR 2.1 trillion, based on claims that Chromebooks were expensive and CDM offered little practical value.
Fact
The procurement of Chromebooks and Chrome Device Management (CDM) actually reduced operating system licensing costs and nation-wide device management expenses. By eliminating recurring operating system license fees and subscription-based management costs, the government achieved savings of at least IDR 1.2 trillion.
Allegation
Allegations have emerged that the procurement of Chromebooks and Chrome Device Management (CDM) caused state financial losses up to IDR 2.1 trillion, based on claims that Chromebooks were expensive and CDM offered little practical value.
Fact
The procurement of Chromebooks and Chrome Device Management (CDM) actually reduced operating system licensing costs and nation-wide device management expenses. By eliminating recurring operating system license fees and subscription-based management costs, the government achieved savings of at least IDR 1.2 trillion.
The free operating system license and a one-time Device Management licensing scheme make Chromebooks, overall, cheaper than laptops in other ecosystems.
The use of Chromebooks in the national ICT procurement program was not a policy that harmed state finances; rather, it was a deliberate cost-efficiency strategy for managing ICT infrastructure at a national scale.
In the context of national ICT procurement, the costs involved are not limited to the purchase of hardware such as laptops. The government must also account for other costs , including:
Operating system (OS) licensing
Centralized device management costs
Compared to laptops using other operating systems such as Windows, these two cost components are significantly lower in the Chromebook ecosystem.
Chromebook Cost Structure
At the time the procurement took place, the Chromebook cost structure consisted of several key elements designed to reduce government spending.
Chrome OS
FREE, or not subject to any additional licensing fee
The operating system cost is already included in the device price
Chrome Device Management (CDM)
One-time license (one-time fee)
Device management one-time fee of USD 30 per laptop
No subscription fee that must be renewed every year
Integrated Learning Applications
Chromebooks provide various integrated learning applications for free
Includes Google Workspace and Google Classroom, with no additional licensing fees
Comparison with Other Operating Systems
As a comparison, laptops using other operating systems such as Windows generates higher and recurring costs, including:
Paid operating system licensing fees per device (not free)
Subscription-based device management, with total management costs that can reach USD 200–230 for three years and must be paid repeatedly
Additional licensing fees for supporting learning software, such as document-processing and presentation tools
At the scale of national procurement, these cost differences save the state budget, not the other way around.
Why Is Chrome Device Management (CDM) Essential?
Device Management referred to in the Chromebook ecosystem as Chrome Device Management (CDM) plays a critical role in ensuring accountability, a utilization monitoring system, long-term risk management, and, most importantly, protecting students from harmful content such as pornography, online gambling, and violent games.
Procurement Accountability
The Ministry of Education, Culture, Research, and Technology (Kemendikbudristek) needs to ensure that ICT devices purchased are properly distributed and received by schools. Device Management enables:
Identifying and monitoring who activates each laptop
Tracking the location and device usage
Collecting utilization data on a regular basis
Utilization Monitoring System
Through CDM, laptop usage can be monitored to ensure devices are used responsibly. Chromebook Device Management allows remote centralized control by the Super Admin (PUSDATIN, Ministry of Education), including the ability to:
Block irrelevant or harmful websites (social media, violent games, pornography, intrusive advertising)
Centrally manage which applications can be installed
Automatically install applications without requiring teachers to install them one by one, thereby significantly reducing training and operational costs across regions
Disable internet access centrally during examinations, such as the National Assessment, to prevent potential cheating
All of these mechanisms ensure that devices are used solely for learning and school administration purposes while minimizing the risk of misuse beyond learning purposes.
As a result of the implementation of Chrome Device Management (CDM), physical audits at schools are no longer required, because each laptop’s usage activity at every school is recorded in real time. For the first time in Indonesia’s history, the conduct of ICT procurement can be 100% transparent and accountable.
This website is continuously updated to provide accurate, verifiable, factual and contextual information as the legal process in the Nadiem Makarim Chromebook case develops
●
This website is continuously updated to provide accurate, verifiable, factual and contextual information as the legal process in the Nadiem Makarim Chromebook case develops
●